| |
|
The health of terrestrial and estuarine biota in the ACE Basin is vulnerable to pollution, since many contaminants are toxic. A common definition of pollution is an undesirable change in the physical, chemical, or biological characteristics of air, water, soil, or food that can adversely affect the health, survival, activities of humans or other living organisms (Miller 1994). There is a wide range pollutants including chemical contaminants, nutrients, and biopollutants. This section will concentrate on chemical contamination of the ACE Basin. (See related section: Water Quality.)
A well-known example of a chemical effect on biota occurred with the wide use of the insecticide DDT. DDT was considered a wonder pesticide that was widely used to control insects in the United States until its ban in the 1970s (Leary and others 1946). DDT was found to cause mortality of non-target organisms, to be persistent in the environment, and to bioaccumulate in organisms. Application of DDT increased mortality in numerous bird species and reduced their reproductive success (Blus 1995). The brown pelican is one of the most sensitive species to DDT (and its metabolites DDD and DDE), which can cause embryo mortality from both tissue degradation and eggshell thinning. In the most extreme case of reproductive impairment reported, only five baby pelicans hatched on Anacapa Island in 1969 out of 1300 nesting attempts. The use of DDT was predominantly responsible for the decline in the brown pelican populations in the US (Blus 1995). The chemicals of primary concern are trace metals and organic contaminants. Numerous trace metals are an essential dietary component at low concentrations for aquatic organisms; however, trace metals also pose a threat to organisms due to their persistence in sediments, toxicity at high concentrations, and tendency to bioaccumulate in biological tissue. Trace metals are naturally occurring elements that are influenced by the natural weathering of basement rock (Williams and others 1994). In addition, trace metal concentrations can be enhanced from industrial and urban associated activities. Lead, chromium, cadmium, copper, zinc, and mercury are trace metals that are commonly enriched in sediments due to anthropogenic activities (Bruland and others 1974, Erlenkeuser and others 1974, Goldberg et al. 1977, Kennish 1992). When a trace metal enters the environment from a natural process it is generally at low levels and not biologically harmful; however, when a trace metal enters the environment from anthropogenic processes, then the increased trace metal levels have the potential to cause biological harm. The organic chemicals commonly associated with anthropogenic processes are polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), pesticides, and polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs ). PAHs are chronically toxic, carcinogenic, and mutagenic to a wide range of biota including aquatic organisms and humans. PAHs are a major component of lubricating oils and fossil fuels. They are released into the environment when these products are spilled or combusted to produce energy. PAHs are also produced during the combustion of naturally occurring organic matter such as during a forest fire. Potential sources of PAHs to streams, rivers, and estuarine tidal creek systems include runoff from highways and parking lots, vehicle exhaust, street dust, fuel spills, marina and recreational boating activities, and atmospheric fallout (Weinstein 1996). Pesticides are organic contaminants of concern particularly in aquatic environments with watersheds that are used for agricultural production (Scott et al. 1994). Pesticides are used to produce a desired effect, usually death, on target organisms. The problem arises when these intentionally used chemicals produce a nondesired effect on non-target organisms. The effects that DDT had on birds as previously described, is one example. Pesticides can cause a wide range of adverse effects on non-target organisms. PCBs are another persistent organic contaminant banned in the 1970s that have been reported to accumulate in estuarine environments (Weinstein 1996). PCBs were commonly used in cooling agents and insulators for capacitors, transformers, gaskets, caulking compounds, paints, and oils (Hutzinger and others 1974, Kennish 1992). PCBs have been found to cause reproductive abnormalities, skin lesions, liver damage, and cancer in various organisms (Kennish 1997). Sources of
Contaminants Atmospheric Inputs
Gases are not the only atmospheric components influencing water chemistry. Particles from numerous sources also occur in water. These can be insoluble, unreactive dust particles or relatively soluble compounds, such as gypsum (calcium sulfate) or limestone (calcium carbonate). Numerous compounds are found in both gaseous and particulate forms. One example is mercury, which can also be introduced via natural sources, industrial outfalls, sewage discharges, and via the atmosphere from incinerators (Windom and others 1975). Mercury is a very toxic compound, which has been linked to a wide range of toxic effects including nervous system damage, reduced growth, and inhibited reproduction (Wren and others 1995). The mercury problem has been well documented in a number of freshwater environments throughout North Carolina and South Carolina. Freshwater environments typically have low pH levels that keep the mercury in solution and hence, bioavailable. The mercury threat to the marine or estuarine environment is less clear due to higher pH values that reduce mercury solubility.
Aquatic Inputs The hydrochemistry influencing the level of contamination and partitioning of contaminants in the environment is complex. All of the research examining the contamination of the ACE Basin has primarily been conducted in the aquatic environment. In general, contaminants that are deposited on land can leach into groundwater or enter an aquatic system through runoff from the terrestrial environment during a rain event. Once pollutants enter the aquatic environment, particularly an estuarine environment, a series of complex factors determine the location of the contaminants in the environment. Most contaminants do not remain dissolved in water, instead they will adsorb to particle surfaces present in the bottom sediment or within the water column, which eventually settle to the bottom sediments. A change in the environmental condition or hydrochemistry can alter the partitioning of contaminants in the environment (e.g., water, sediment, tissue) and the ultimate fate of the contaminant.
Relatively high concentrations of metals are found in acidic water, since most metals are soluble at low pHs. The so-called blackwater rivers are black or dark brown due to the presence of humic acids, which come from leaves and other sources. In these environments, some metals are found at concentrations hundreds of times greater than those in seawater. For example, the iron concentration in river water is 670 ppb, but in seawater it is <5 ppb (Goldberg 1967). Most of the data presented in this section will involve the level of sediment contamination present in the ACE Basin. Emphasis on sediment chemical contamination is related to the fact that sediments are an environmental sink for chemical contaminants. In order to understand what the level of contamination in the ACE Basin indicates, the chemical concentrations found in the ACE Basin will be compared to the contaminant concentrations in other estuarine systems as well as to contaminant concentrations known to cause biological effects. This potential for a biological effect from sediment chemical concentrations will be described using the effects range-low (ER-L ) and the effects range-median (ER-M ) as defined by Long and Morgan (1990) and Long and others (1995). The ER-L and ER-M are concentrations associated with biological effects from a large collection of biological experiments and field assessments. The ER-L and ER-M values are defined as the concentrations at which 10% and 50% of the studies showed a biological effect at specific concentrations, respectively. Values below the ER-L would rarely be expected to be associated with measurable biological effects. Values between the ER-L and ER-M represent a range in which there are possible biological effects for a wide range of organisms. Values above the ER-M represent a range above which there are probable biological effects for a wide range of organisms. In the description of data for the ACE Basin, ER-L and ER-M values will be used to identify those sites with the highest potential for biological effects. In 1994 to 1996, a study funded by the ACE Basin National Estuarine Research
Reserve (NERR) and the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration,
National Ocean Service (NOAA-NOS) was performed to determine recent sediment
contamination in the ACE Basin NERR (Scott et al. 1998). Data collected for
this study were designed to serve as a baseline of chemical concentrations in
the relatively undeveloped and pristine ACE Basin. The chemical concentrations
are expected to increase as development in the ACE Basin occurs. The study
design involved sampling eight sites in the Combahee River, eight sites in the
Edisto River, eight sites in the Ashepoo River, three sites in St. Helena
Sound, and seven sites in the Intracoastal Waterway or adjoining small tidal
creeks in the region for both trace metals
and organic contaminant
concentrations. Two of these sites, A and B, are located in Big Bay Creek and
St. Pierre Creek, respectively. These two sites are part of the ACE Basin NERR
long-term monitoring stations for water quality (See
sediment sampling sites
The level of sediment contamination was low throughout the Basin study area; however, there was some variability in the contaminant concentrations among sites (Scott et al. 1998). In general, the sites with the highest contaminant concentrations were also the sites with high clay content. These findings are not surprising since contaminants preferentially bind to clay over sand particles. Therefore, the increased contaminant levels at these sites is probably due to the sediment type and not a contaminant source. For example, 62% and 55% of the sediment in Big Bay Creek (A) and St. Pierre Creek (B), respectively, was clay particles. These two sites generally had higher contaminant concentrations compared to the majority of sites sampled. Water quality research at these two sites has not found any abnormal values for the various variables measured. Scott et al. (1998) found the level of sediment trace metal
contamination in the ACE Basin NERR to be low. Only arsenic was found in high
enough concentrations to exceed the ER-L
level. Ten of the 34 sites had
sediment arsenic concentrations exceeding the ER-L level but not the ER-M
level
(Comparison of bottom sediment
contaminants
The overall level of sediment organic contamination in the ACE Basin was also found to be low. Sediment concentrations of PAHs were similar to concentrations reported at other pristine NERR sites (i.e., North Inlet NERR). Scott et. al. (1998) concluded the concentrations of PAHs found in the ACE Basin are reflective of atmospheric inputs into the region. None of the PAHs were found to exceed the ER-L or ER-M levels. The maximum total PAH concentration found in the ACE Basin was only 299 ppb while the ER-L level is 4,022 ppb. This indicates that there is little potential for a toxic effect in the ACE Basin due to PAHs. The PCB and organochlorine pesticide concentrations were also found to be very low in the ACE Basin. All 34 of the sites sampled had PCB and organochlorine pesticide concentrations well below the ER-L or ER-M levels. There appears to be little input of these types of contaminants into the ACE Basin (Scott et al. 1998). This is not surprising considering PCBs are an urban-derived contaminant that was banned in the US in the 1970s. Organochlorine pesticide use also appears to be very low in the area considering the level of contamination found in the sediment. Therefore, there is a low likelihood that any biological effects would be observed in relation to the organic contamination of the sediment. The Environmental Monitoring and Assessment Program The Environmental Monitoring and Assessment Program Carolinian
Province (EMAP-CP) is another study that sampled in the ACE Basin. One of the
objectives of the EMAP-CP was to assess the estuarine
sediment
contamination
from North Carolina to Florida (Hyland et. al. 1996 and 1998). Over a two-year
period, the EMAP-CP sampled six
sites
Alexander and Wenner (1995) evaluated the historical record of trace metal flux into the ACE Basin from nonpoint sources of pollution. To perform this study, 40 to 55 cm (16 to 22 in) deep sediment cores were collected at two different sites. The first site was subtidal in the Fenwick Cut, which joins the South Edisto and Ashepoo Rivers. The second site was intertidal on a nearby salt marsh. The sediment accumulation rate (> 5 cm/mo, > 2 in/yr) at the subtidal site limited the historical record to the last year of metal and sediment flux. This subtidal core indicated that there were pulses of sediment and metals, especially chromium and zinc, throughout the year. The intertidal core showed approximately 130 years of sediment and metal accumulation at a rate of 0.42 cm/yr (0.17 in/yr). This core demonstrates a gradual increase in trace metal concentrations to the region for the last 80 years. The fluxes of all metals, except arsenic, exhibit a 1.5 to 3.0 times increase in metal concentrations over the length of the core (Alexander and Wenner 1995). In addition to these large-scale studies, several other research projects on contaminants have been performed in the ACE Basin. Both sediment and oyster tissues collected in St. Helena Sound were generally lower in all contaminants than those from the Charleston Harbor system (Mathews unpubl. data). Similar results were reported for pesticides in samples taken on St. Helena Island (Knowles 1983). Although pesticides might be expected to be reasonably high in St. Helena Sound due to farming in the area, this does not appear to be the case. One explanation for lack of pesticide contamination is that circulation in the sound may not allow for their accumulation. The volume of freshwater flowing into St. Helena Sound is 362 m3/s (1188 ft3/s) (NOAA 1985). This flow rate is the third highest in the state following Charleston Harbor and Winyah Bay. Such a high volume of water may effectively flush the sound of contaminants. In addition, the pesticides used by agricultural operations may have naturally degraded over time. A decrease in the agricultural industry in the ACE Basin will presumably keep the level of pesticide contamination in the area low. (See related section: Agriculture.) However, an increase in urban development may counteract the decrease in agriculture considering pesticides are applied to lawns and golf courses. Despite the low level of contamination in the ACE Basin, a few studies have found limited areas of sediment contamination. Marcus and Mathews (1987) found a mixture of PCBs in the sediments of Campbell Creek on Whale Branch, which connects with St. Helena Sound via the Coosaw River. A chemical plant is located near this creek. Sediment PCB concentrations at this site were up to 24,200 ppb, or almost 2500 times greater than those found downstream near the sound (Marcus and Mathews 1987). This concentration of PCBs is over a 130 times higher than the ER-M value. An adverse biological effect from PCB concentrations in the sediment is highly probable. PCB concentrations in blue crabs ranged from an average of 861 ppb near the chemical plant outfall to below detection limits <20 ppb for those from the South Edisto River (Marcus and Mathews 1987). In addition, a wide variety of synthetic organic chemicals rarely found along our coast were detected both in the sediments and oyster tissues of Campbell Creek, including diphenyl-methanone, 1,2,3-trichlorobenzene, and 9,10-anthracendione (Marcus and Swearingen 1985). This indicates that controlling the levels of chemical contaminants entering the aquatic environment from industrial development is very important as the ACE Basin continues to be developed. Wood for docks and bulkheads is usually treated with an antifouling agent to increase the longevity of the structure. One antifouling agent is chromated copper arsenate or CCA. Weis and Weis (1995) explored the impacts of CCA on the biota adjacent to CCA-treated docks and bulkheads in four NERR sites, including the ACE Basin. Sediment and polychaete tissue samples were taken immediately adjacent to the treated surface and at intervals of 1, 3, and 10 m (3.3, 9.8, and 32.8 ft) from the structure to determine whether chromium, copper, or arsenic concentrations could be detected. Elevated levels of the three constituents, chromium, copper, and arsenic (CCA) were found in some sediments and polychaetes near a CCA-treated bulkhead in a residential canal in the North Inlet, SC NERR. They also recorded reduced diversity and biomass of benthic organisms. In the same area, but near an aluminum bulkhead, these deleterious effects were not observed. In the three other NERRs, including the ACE Basin NERR, with only docks and no bulkheads, the negative effects of the CCA-treated wood were absent. Therefore, it appears if only pilings are present and the system is well flushed, then there are no negative biological effects (Weis and Weis 1995). Other Contaminant Data
The ACE Basin is a unique system that is presently a pristine environment with regard to its levels of chemical pollution. The potential for pollution is, however, present due to the likelihood of chemical contaminants entering the ACE Basin from outside sources. The two main outside sources of contaminants are atmospheric inputs and aquatic inputs from upstream anthropogenic activities. These external pressures cannot be controlled to any great extent from within the Basin. In the near future, there is also the potential for pollution to enter the ACE Basin from development of the terrestrial environment in the surrounding watershed. Unlike outside sources, these internal contaminant sources can be regulated by land use planning and government regulations. As pressure for more residential and industrial development increases, controlling point and nonpoint sources of pollution will need to be a high priority. A study by the SCDNR/Marine Resources Research Institute (SCDNR/MRRI) found adverse effects on the South Carolina tidal creek biological community when the amount of impervious surface was greater than 30-35% (Holland and others 1997, Lerberg 1997). In addition, this study found a significant correlation between the amount of impervious surface and contaminant concentrations in the sediments of tidal creeks (Sanger 1998). This indicates that as impervious surface on land increases, then contaminant loadings in creek sediments increase. Therefore, land use planning in the ACE Basin study area will be a very important aspect of keeping chemical concentrations low. Authors T. Mathews, SCDNR Marine Resources Research Institute D. Sanger, SCDNR Marine Resources Research Institute Alexander, C. and E. Wenner. 1995. Evaluating the historical record of nonpoint source pollution in the ACE Basin and Sapelo Island National Estuarine Research Reserves. Final Report, SC Sea Grant Consortium, Charleston, SC. Blus, L. J. 1995. Organochlorine pesticides. In: Hoffman, D. J., B. A. Rattner, G. A. Burton, Jr., and J. Cairns, Jr. (eds.). Handbook of ecotoxicology. CRC Press, Inc., Boca Raton, FL. Bruland, K. W., K. Bertine, M. Koide, and E. D. Goldberg. 1974. History of heavy metal pollution in Southern California coastal zone. Environmental Science and Technology 8:425-432. Erlenkeuser, H. E., D. R. Suess, and H. Willkomm. 1974. Industrialization affects heavy metal and carbon isotope concentrations in recent Baltic Sea sediments. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 38:832-842. Goldberg, E. D. 1967. Minor elements in sea water. In: Riley, J. P. and G. Skirrow (eds.). Chemical oceanography, Vol. I. Academic Press, London. Goldberg, E. D., E. Gamble, J. J. Griffin, and M. Koide. 1977. Pollution history of Narragansett Bay as recorded in its sediments. Estuarine and Coastal Marine Science 5:549-561. Holland A. F., G. H. M. Riekerk, S. B. Lerberg, L. E. Zimmerman, and D. M. Sanger. (1997). Assessment of the impact of watershed development on the nursery functions of tidal creek habitats. In: Stepan C. D. and K. Beidler (eds.). Management of Atlantic coastal marine fish habitat: proceedings of a workshop for habitat managers. Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission, Philadelphia, PA. Hyland, J. L., T. J. Herrlinger, T. R. Snoots, A. H. Ringwood, R. F. Van Dolah, C. T. Hackney, G. A. Nelson, J. S. Rosen, and S. A. Kokkinakis. 1996. Environmental quality of estuaries of the Carolinian Province: 1994. Annual statistical summary for the 1994 EMAP-Estuaries Demonstration Project in the Carolinian Province. NOAA Technical Memorandum NOS ORCA 123. NOAA/NOS, Office of Ocean Resources Conservation and Assessment, Silver Spring, MD. Hyland, J. L., L. Balthis, C. T. Hackney, G. McRae, A. H. Ringwood, T. R. Snoots, R. F. Van Dolah, and T. L. Wade. 1998. Environmental quality of estuaries of the Carolinian Province: 1995. Annual statistical summary for the 1995 EMAP-Estuaries Demonstration Project in the Carolinian Province. NOAA Technical Memorandum NOS ORCA 97. NOAA/NOS, Office of Ocean Resources Conservation and Assessment, Silver Spring, MD. Hutzinger, O., S. Safe, and V. Zitko. 1974. The chemistry of PCBs. CRC Press Inc., Cleveland, OH. Kennish, M. J. 1992. Ecology of estuaries: anthropogenic effects. CRC Press Inc., Boca Raton, FL. Kennish, M. J. 1997. Practical handbook of estuarine and marine pollution. CRC Press Inc., Boca Raton, FL. Knowles, S. C. 1983. Pesticide analyses at selected drainages on St. Helena Island, Beaufort County, to Trenchards Inlet. Technical Report 0200-83. SC Department of Health and Environmental Control, Columbia, SC. Leary, J. C., M. I. Fishbein, and L. C. Salter. 1946. DDT and the insect problem. McGraw-Hill Book Company Inc., New York. Lerberg, S. B. (1997) Effects of watershed development on macrobenthic communities in the tidal creeks of the Charleston Harbor Estuary Master's Thesis. University of Charleston, Charleston, SC. Long, E. R. and L. G. Morgan. 1990. The potential for biological effects of sediment-sorbed contaminants tested in the National Status and Trends Program. NOAA Technical Memorandum NOS OMA 52. Seattle, WA. Long, E. R., D. R. MacDonald, S. L. Smith, and F. D. Calder. 1995. Incidence of adverse biological effects within ranges of chemical concentrations in marine and estuarine sediments. Environmental Management 19(1):81-97. Long, E. R., G. I. Scott, J. Kucklick, M. Fulton, B. Thompson, R. S. Carr, J. Biedenbach, K. J. Scott, G. B. Thursby, G. T. Chandler, J. W. Anderson, and G. M. Sloane. 1998. Magnitude and extent of sediment toxicity in selected estuaries of South Carolina and Georgia. NOAA Technical Memorandum NOS ORCA 128. Silver Springs, MD. Marcus, J. M. and T. D. Mathews. 1987. Polychlorinated biphenyls in blue crabs from South Carolina. Bulletin of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology 39:857-862. Marcus, J. M. and G. R. Swearingen. 1985. A summary of water quality sampling activities at Campbell Creek, Beaufort County, South Carolina-November 14-15, 1983 through December 5, 1984. SC Department of Health and Environmental Control, Technical Report 003-85. Marshall, W. D. (ed.). 1993. Assessing change in the Edisto River Basin: an ecological characterization. South Carolina Water Resources Commission, Report No. 177, Columbia, South Carolina. 149p. Mathews, T. Unpublished data. South Carolina Department of Natural Resources, Marine Resources Research Institute, Charleston, South Carolina. Miller, G. T. 1994. Living in the environment: principles, connections, and solutions, 8th edition. Wadsworth, Belmont, CA. NOAA. 1985. National Estuarine Inventory-Data Atlas, Volume I: Physical and Hydrologic Characteristics. US Department of Commerce, NOAA, Washington, DC. NOAA. 1996. NOAA's estuarine eutrophication survey, Volume 1: South Atlantic Region. Office of Ocean Resources Conservation and Assessment, NOS, Silver Spring, MD. Sanger, D. M. 1998. Physical, chemical, and biological environmental quality of tidal creeks and salt marshes in South Carolina estuaries. Dissertation. University of South Carolina, Columbia, SC. Scott, G. I., M. H. Fulton, D. W. Moore, G. T. Chandler, P. B. Key, T. W. Hampton, J. M. Marcus, K. L. Jackson, D. S. Baughman, A. H. Trim, L. Williams, C. J. Louden, and E. R. Patterson. 1994. Agricultural insecticide runoff effects on estuarine organisms: correlating laboratory and field toxicity testing, ecophysiology assays, and ecotoxicological biomonitoring. Report EPA/600/R-94/004; Report PB94-160678. University of South Carolina, School of Public Health, Columbia, SC. Scott, G. I., M. H. Fulton, R. F. Van Dolah, P. B. Key, J. W. Daugomah, P. P. Maier, E. F. Wirth, M. Levison, N. Hadley, S. Layman, B. C. Thompson, E. D. Strozier, and P. L. Pennington. 1994. Ecotoxicological assessment of effluent and sediments from the Savannah Harbor dredged materials disposal areas in Wright River Estuary of South Carolina. USDOC/NOAA/NMFS/SEFSC/Charleston Laboratory, Marine Ecotoxicology Division, Charleston, SC. Scott, G. I., M. H. Fulton, D. Bearden, M. Sanders, A. Dias, L. A. Reed, S. Sivertsen, E. D. Strozier, P. B. Jenkins, J. W. Daugomah, J. DeVane, P. B. Key, and W. Ellenberg. 1998. Chemical contaminant levels in estuarine sediment of the Ashepoo-Combahee-Edisto River (ACE) Basin National Estuarine Research Reserve and Sanctuary Site. US Department of Commerce, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, National Ocean Service, Charleston, SC. United States Environmental Protection Agency, Office of Water. 1998. STORET Database. http://www.epa.gov/owow/storet/index.html (accessed August 1998). Weinstein, J. E. 1996. Anthropogenic impacts on salt marshes. In: Vernberg F. J., W. B. Vernberg, T. Siewicki (eds.). Sustainable development in the southeastern coastal zone. University of South Carolina Press, Columbia, SC. Weis, J. S. and P. Weis. 1995. Benthic impacts of wood treated with chromated copper arsenate (CCA) in estuaries. Final Report for Grant #NA470R0200, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, Silver Spring, MD. Williams, T. P., J. M. Bubb and J. N. Lester. 1994. Metal accumulation within salt marsh environments: a review. Marine Pollution Bulletin 28:277-290. Windom, H. L., F. E. Taylor, and E. M. Waiters. 1975. Possible influence of atmospheric transport on the total mercury content of southeastern Atlantic Continental Shelf surface waters. Deep-Sea Research 22:629-633. Wren, C. D., S. Harris, and N. A. Harttrup. 1995. Ecotoxicology of Mercury and Cadmium. In: D. J. Hoffman, B. A. Rattner, G. A. Burton, Jr., and J. Cairns, Jr. (eds.). Handbook of Ecotoxicology, CRC Press Inc., Boca Raton, FL. |